A warning to delinquent company owners and directors: Sevilleja v Marex Financial Ltd

By · 23 July 2020 · 5 min read

← Back

It is the ultimate pyrrhic victory in civil litigation against an incorporated Defendant to win the case but find yourself holding a worthless piece of paper, a judgment against an insolvent company which has been asset-stripped by its directors, especially when you find yourself in a queue of other creditors with equally worthless claims.  The Insolvency Act regime is designed to achieve fairness between the creditors and the controlling minds of the company will seek to avoid direct liability for the losses by arguing that the claims against them (if any) belong not to the creditor but to the company.  The principle of  “no claim for reflective loss” has long prevented wronged shareholder creditors from pursuing directors (Prudential Assurance v Newman Industries [1982] Ch 204) and this was given wider currency by the decision in Johnson v Gore Wood [2002] 2 AC 1.

The Supreme Court has now tackled head on the iniquity of a wronged non-shareholder creditor who has ended up with an empty judgment as a result of the owners of a company deliberately asset-stripping it to avoid paying up.   In Sevilleja v Marex Financial Ltd [2020] UKSC 31 an application had been made to Knowles J to set aside an order giving permission for service of proceedings on Mr Sevilleja out of the jurisdiction. One of the arguments advanced by Mr Sevilleja in support of his application was that Marex did not have a good arguable case against him because the losses it was seeking to recover were reflective of loss suffered by two companies which had concurrent claims against him. The judge held that Marex had a good arguable case that its claim was not precluded by the “reflective loss” principle and therefore dismissed Mr Sevilleja’s application but the Court of Appeal disagreed and held that only 10% of the Marex claim was not precluded by the reflective loss principle.  Since the original judgment was for 5.5 million US dollars this represented a very big loss.  Marex had been put into liquidation by its owner in what was described as “a device to thwart enforcement of a $5m judgment against the companies that Marex won in the courts of England and the most blatant effort to hinder, delay and defraud a creditor this Court has ever seen.”   Marex therefore pursued a direct claim against Mr Sevilleja in the law of tort.

The stage was thus set for a full (seven judge) panel of the Supreme Court to discuss at length the principles and objectives of company law and the rules against double recovery.  Underlying the decision however must surely have been the Court’s distaste for the activities of the owner of this company and the obvious need to avoid an injustice to the creditor without inflicting serious injury on established law.  By a convoluted route the Court held that whilst a shareholder’s loss in respect of a diminution in share value was not separate and distinct from the damage suffered by the company (and therefore unrecoverable), the rule in Prudential did not apply in the instant case since it did not concern a shareholder. Accordingly, Marex was entitled to pursue the entirety of its claim. 

The following extract from the judgment of Lord helps to explain the Court’s thinking: “The reflective loss principle as stated in Prudential is a flimsy foundation on which to build outwards into other areas of the law……..Marex was not a shareholder in the companies, but their creditor……a creditor of a company has not chosen ………to follow the fortunes of the company in the same way as a shareholder. Subject to the company having sufficient assets, whether the creditor gets paid or not does not depend on the decision of the directors, as payment of a dividend to a shareholder does: when armed with a court judgment the creditor can execute it against the assets of the company. Moreover, there is a clear mechanism available to meet the problem of possible double recovery against the defendant in respect of the loss suffered by Marex and the loss suffered by the companies. To the extent that Marex sues Mr Sevilleja and obtains recovery from him for the judgment sum, Mr Sevilleja can be subrogated to Marex’s rights against the companies or allowed a right of reimbursement in respect of them.  If Marex’s debtor had been an individual and Mr Sevilleja had stolen all his assets with a view to preventing him paying the debt due to Marex, it would be possible for Marex to bring a…claim against him…..”. 

The lesson for delinquent directors is obvious for all to see.

Derek Marshall is the Head of College Chambers and Head of the Chancery and Commercial team there.  He is a very experienced civil practitioner, an Arbitrator and Civil Dispute Mediator and sits as an LQC on the Police Conduct Panel.  To instruct Derek please contact Clerks@college-chambers.co.uk

← Back

Memberships & Awards

Legal 500 Shortlisted 2025 Set of the Year
Legal 500 2025 Recommended Set
Legal 500 2025 Leading Junior
Legal 500 2025 Leading Mediator
Legal 500 2025 Leading Set
Legal 500 2025 Included Clerk
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
Wellbeing at the Bar | Certificate of Recognition
Family Law Awards 2020 - Family Law Chambers of the Year
Civil Mediation Council
Family Law Bar Association
Professional Negligence Bar Association
Chancery Bar
Resolution first for family law