Bundles for Delinquents.
Sir James Munby’s final warning on bundles in Family Proceedings
I happened to be before the President of the Family Division last week on the very day he handed down the judgment in L (A Child), Re [2015] EWFC 15 (26 February 2015). This is a judgment regarding a public law care case in which Sir James Munby expressed his frustration and exasperation at the amount of documents being submitted in court saying it happened “too often”. In his damning judgment as to bundles and practitioners at the family courts he referred to PD 27 which states that unless the court has directed otherwise, parties can submit a bundle of no more than 350 sides of text. He said, however this rule is “frequently, indeed in some places routinely ignored”.
He continues in his judgment to say “This practice must stop and I have taken practical steps to stop it,’ he said. "From now on, counter-staff at court offices will be instructed to refuse to accept witness bundles, unless a judge has specifically directed that they are to be lodged, and to require whoever is trying to lodge them to take them away.”
“If witness bundles are sent by post, or by DX or delivered by couriers who refuse to take them away, they will, unless a judge has specifically directed that they are to be lodged, be destroyed without any prior warning necessarily being given. They will not be delivered to the judge and will not be taken into the courtroom by court staff.”
Munby said defaulters can have no complaint if they are exposed to public condemnation in judgments. Excessive bundles may also be subject to financial penalties.
“It is no use the court continuing feebly to issue empty threats" he added. “From now on delinquents can expect to find themselves subject to effective sanctions.”
In the judgment itself ( which were care proceedings) there were 989 pages worth of documents in the court bundle, including 131 pages of witness statements from the mother of the children concerned. The father of one of the children was from Slovenia and could not speak English. As a result, his solicitors had requested translations of the 591 pages which would cost £23,000.
Sitting at the Royal Courts of Justice in London, Sir James Munby said that it was only really necessary to have 51 pages translated. He added that, before a final hearing took place, the father’s solicitors should produce a summary of the “important substance” which should be no longer than 30 pages.
Although this was related to a care case, this Practice Direction refers to all family proceedings including Financial remedies.
Last week the matter I was involved in was a directions hearing in a family finance case and unfortunately for my opponent, they had filed a bundle in late and one that was in foolscap. The President expressed his frustration at my opponent hot off the judgment he had just delivered, referring to paragraph 15 of this judgment “ PD27A para 5.1 requires the bundle to be contained in an "A4 size ring binder or lever arch file" (emphasis added). Too often this requirement is ignored and the bundle is contained in a foolscap binder or lever arch file. This will not do.”
The President said this was not pedantry but the rules were there for a reason. Neither Counsel thought it was wise to inform the President that local practices vary as to the bundles at directions hearings, some courts even having local protocols dispensing with need for PD27 compliant bundles. Perhaps local practice especially before District Judges will change?
Those of you who practice in Civil law will know that in Civil Proceedings there are sanctions for non-compliance with Court orders and CPR. Following the decision of Mitchell and now Denton, the default position of a breach of a rule or court order is a strict enforcement, for which relief must be sought under CPR 3.9. I do wonder, if the default position for family proceedings is that the Court bundle will be destroyed or not allowed due to non compliance of PD27, will we be looking at similar relief from sanction applications?
You have been warned, and so had my opponent; don’t risk being called a delinquent or face consequences of non-compliance of PD27, you must get your bundles in order.
Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.














