Carry On Assessing...

By · 1 April 2010 · 4 min read

← Back

"A serious case that raised serious issues" was the comment of Family Law Magazine in its December 2009 issue [2009 FL1129], discussing the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Re L [2009] EWCA Civ 1008. The case is of great importance to all family lawyers because it deals with some fundamental principles which should inform any court's approach to care proceedings. The facts were that a six-month old baby had suffered severe injuries which were in the words of Wall LJ, "paradigmatic of abuse." There were a number of people potentially in the frame as perpetrators including both parents and some of the grandparents. In addition, there were criminal proceedings as yet unresolved in which the father was alleged to have been the perpetrator and the mother was charged with cruelty and neglect on the basis that she knew what the father was doing and failed to report him to the authorities. The circuit judge held a fact finding hearing at which she concluded that she could not rule out either parent as abuser (both denying culpability) and that there had been a "global family failure to protect the child" by all the parents and grandparents and, in consequence, he would have to be adopted outside the family. In the meantime, a local authority parenting assessment on the mother reported that she was committed to any work necessary to regain her child. This assessment had been undertaken largely prior to the fact finding judgment, but the judgment was not discussed with the mother before the report was filed. The mother naturally applied for a risk assessment on herself to be carried out by a well known and reputable organisation: Summarily refused by the circuit judge on the ground that the terms of the fact finding finding judgment were so clear as not to permit any further delay. She directed the local authority to file a care plan and its placement application and set the case down for a final hearing to take place the week before the criminal case was due to begin. The Court of Appeal had no difficulty in reversing that order and directing a risk assessment. Further, the Court ruled that the requirement for judicial continuity was over-ridden by the appearance of unfairness to the mother and directed that a different judge should take the final hearing. It also vacated the fixture and directed that the final hearing should follow the criminal trial and not precede it.

The reader is invited to read the commentary in Family Law Magazine, which includes a full discussion of the case. However, the judgment itself is of huge importance because it sets out once again the frame work against which care cases are decided. It seems now that in most, if not all, cases an assessment is needed after the fact find so that parents can be shown and if necessary confronted with the findings in that judgment. In addition, where there are interlinked care and criminal proceedings, thought should be given in every case to how the two should proceed, and whether a fact find is necessary at all where, as here, the medical evidence was not disputed.

As Counsel for the mother throughout, I was conscious that important principles were at stake and was glad that the Court of Appeal took the opportunity to give general guidance on the law and the practice. In the meantime the message seems to be "carry on assessing...!"

Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.

← Back

Memberships & Awards

Legal 500 Shortlisted 2025 Set of the Year
Legal 500 2025 Recommended Set
Legal 500 2025 Leading Junior
Legal 500 2025 Leading Mediator
Legal 500 2025 Leading Set
Legal 500 2025 Included Clerk
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
Wellbeing at the Bar | Certificate of Recognition
Family Law Awards 2020 - Family Law Chambers of the Year
Civil Mediation Council
Family Law Bar Association
Professional Negligence Bar Association
Chancery Bar
Resolution first for family law