Contact With New-Born Babies In Care
On 15 April 2003, Munby J (as he then was) delivered his judgment in the case of Re M [2003] 2 FLR 171. He said at paragraph 44(iv) ‘If a baby is to be removed from his mother one would normally expect arrangements to be made by the local authority to facilitate contact on a regular and generous basis. ... Typically, if this is what the parents want, one will be looking to contact most days of the week and for lengthy periods. … Contact two or three times a week for a couple of hours a time is simply not enough if parents reasonably want more.’
Re M was a judicial review application by the parents to restrain the local authority from issuing public law proceedings in respect of their as yet unborn child.
Bodey J considered Re M in Kirklees Metropolitan District Council v S [2006] 1 FLR 333, a case involving a one-month-old baby. He noted that Munby J’s views cited above were obiter dicta and said at paragraph 32 that an order for daily contact to a child in care ‘is on any view (to put it at its lowest) exceptionally unusual’; each case would have to be looked at one is own particular merits. He added at paragraph 41 that the local authority should supply evidence in support of any contention that resources are relevant. Remitting the matter back to the Family Proceedings Court, he concluded at paragraph 42: ‘Unless rehabilitation can be seen as being likely in the near future, I would respectfully suggest that an order involving all or most weekdays, but not weekends (or at least not every Saturday and every Sunday) might be regarded as the appropriate way forward.’
There has been no further reported word on the subject from the higher courts.
Re M and Kirklees became routinely relied-upon by advocates for parents contending for extensive contact.
Then in 2009 Jenny Kenrick, a psychotherapist, published her paper ‘Concurrent planning: A retrospective study of the continuities and discontinuities of care and their impact on the development of infant and young children placed for adoption by the Coram Concurrent Planning project’ (2009) 33(4) Adoption and Fostering 5-18. She argued that over-regular contact was highly disruptive to infants who have an overriding need to form positive attachments with their foster carers; such children may already be disadvantaged by parental substance misuse in utero and/or abusive parenting during their very early lives. Regular, perhaps lengthy, journeys to and from contact with no consistency of staff accompanying the child on the journey or supervising the contact was disruptive and foster carers reported the effects.
At a President’s Debate in December 2010, Munby LJ (as he then was), echoed these concerns and said that the emphasis should be on the word ‘reasonably’ in the phrase ‘if parents reasonably want more’.
It has become common practice for local authorities to quote the Kenrick research in support of more limited levels of contact.
An Australian paper echoed Kenrick’s views (C Humphreys and M Kiraly, ‘High-frequency family contact: a road to nowhere for infants' (2011) 16(1) Child and Family Social Work 111) and argued that there was no correlation between frequency of contact and likelihood of an ultimate return home to natural parents.
Both the Kenrick and the Australian paper were criticised by Peter Dale in his 2011 paper ‘Restriction on natural parent contact with infants during care proceedings some cautions about recent research and developing practice.’ Dale questioned the independence of Kenrick, the small scale of her research, the below-average rates of return to natural parents of the children considered and Kenrick’s focus on accounts from adoptors.
In July 2012 Martin Narey, then Ministerial Advisor on Adoption, issued on behalf of the Department of Education a ‘Call for Views: Review of Contact Arrangements for Children in Care’ with a closing date for responses of 31.8.12. (Embarrassingly, only one lawyer and one member of the judiciary responded.)
The Government has published its summary of feedback and response and proposed amendments to Children Act 1989 s.34 which appear in the Children and Families Bill 2012/13, expected to be passed in April 2014. The Secretary of State will be granted the power by regulations to make provision ‘as to what a local authority in England must have regard to in considering whether contact between a child and a [parent etc.] is consistent with safeguarding and promoting the child’s welfare.’
The resulting picture is confusing for the courts, lawyers and social workers. My experience, which I suspect matches those of other practitioners, is that two or three times per week is a not untypical level of contact; rather below the Kirklees anticipated levels.
The time is ripe for guidance from the Court of Appeal to consider law, academic research and practice on the ground and to set out fresh guidance.
Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.














