Re S (A Child) [2014] Ewca Civ 25

By · 1 April 2014 · 3 min read

← Back

This recent decision has highlighted a few issues for fact-finding hearings and "NAI". In this case a young child had suffered a head injury. At a fact-finding hearing the Judge found that the family were lying about the cause of the injury but could not find the injury was deliberately inflicted by the parents. The local authority had run their case solely on the basis of intentional infliction of injury. The local authority appealed. The appeal was dismissed.

A number of points are to be gleaned from this decision.

The term "non-accidental injury" is a tautology. An accident is something unexpected and unintentional, whereas injury involves an element of wrong, as such it may encompass negligence, recklessness or deliberate infliction. Whilst it may be helpful to be able to distinguish deliberate harm from, say negligence, such distinction is not necessary to consider whether the threshold criteria are satisfied. It is therefore clearer to focus on the statutory requirements.

Care needs to be taken by the Local Authority when putting the case to the Court so that they do not unintentionally limit their case to one potential scenario, as if the realm of potential causes is not explored with expert witnesses the Court may find "a piece of the jigsaw missing" when considering the case in the round.

Fact-finding hearings should only take place in cases where there is a stark and discrete issue which once determined would lead to an early final determination of the proceedings. Where there are other welfare or care issues which will need further determination by the Court there should not be a split hearing even if this would not effect the timetable of the case. If the Court does not hear evidence on the background circumstances to be able to put the allegations in context, such as capability, risk and factors which relate to the credibility of witnesses, it is deprived of "the very material (i.e. secondary facts) upon which findings as to primary fact and social welfare context are often based and tends to undermine the safety of the findings thereby made". The passage of time from the split hearing to the final hearing may also effect the welfare assessment due to memories of the evidence fading and circumstances moving on.

Allegations do not need to be determined by the Court before any social care assessment can be undertaken as such assessment may set out what risks there may be in each of the potential factual scenarios.

The decision in Re S relates to public law proceedings and does not affect private law children cases within which fact-finding hearings are still to be considered in accordance with the guidance provided In the matter of C (Children) [2009] EWCA Civ 994 and the new practice direction 12j (dated April 2014).

Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.

← Back

Memberships & Awards

Legal 500 Shortlisted 2025 Set of the Year
Legal 500 2025 Recommended Set
Legal 500 2025 Leading Junior
Legal 500 2025 Leading Mediator
Legal 500 2025 Leading Set
Legal 500 2025 Included Clerk
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
Wellbeing at the Bar | Certificate of Recognition
Family Law Awards 2020 - Family Law Chambers of the Year
Civil Mediation Council
Family Law Bar Association
Professional Negligence Bar Association
Chancery Bar
Resolution first for family law