Removal From The Jurisdiction: Still A Payne?

By · 1 October 2011 · 3 min read

← Back

...Perhaps not! This topic has been the focus of much academic and legal debate in recent times. In timely fashion the Court of Appeal handed down the decision of MK v CK [2011] EWCA Civ 793 on 7 July 2011. The case considered the significance of the well-known decision of Payne v Payne (2001) EWCA Civ 166. The Appellant father appealed against a decision allowing the mother to relocate with the two children to Canada. The children were aged four and two; the mother was of Canadian origin. Following their divorce a shared residence order was made allowing the children to spend five nights with the father and nine nights with the mother every 14 days. The mother applied for leave to remove, citing she felt isolated and stressed and wished to return to Canada to live with her parents and for family support. The father contested on the basis of his commitment to the children and the shared residence situation. A CAFCASS report recommended the application be refused and that the balance came down against the move. The judge however rejected the recommendation and referred to the effect that such refusal would have on the mother, directing herself to the guidance set out in Payne.

The Court of Appeal found for the father. In the first instance there was a clear recommendation from CAFCASS which the judge had rejected and had offered no real analysis why.

Thorpe LJ set out that as the father was providing much care and input into the children’s lives the judge should have considered Re Y (Leave to Remove from Jurisdiction) [2004] 2 FLR 330 rather than Payne. The only principle to be extracted from Payne was the paramountcy principle. All the rest was guidance as to factors to be weighed in search of the welfare paramountcy. The Payne guidance was given on the basis that the applicant was the primary carer. It was the practical arrangements for sharing the burden of care between two equally committed carers which was significant, rather than the label "shared residence". Where each was providing a more or less equal proportion and one sought to locate externally, the approach which was suggested in Payne should not be utilised; the judge should instead exercise his discretion to grant or refuse the application by applying the statutory checklist in the Children Act 1989, s1(3). The only authentic principle in relocation authorities was that the child’s welfare was the Court’s paramount consideration.

So what of non-shared residence cases? Even where the case concerned a true primary carer, there was no presumption that the reasonable relocation plans of that carer would be facilitated. When a relocation application fell to be determined, all the facts needed to be considered, Payne and Re Y considered.

Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.

← Back

Memberships & Awards

Legal 500 Shortlisted 2025 Set of the Year
Legal 500 2025 Recommended Set
Legal 500 2025 Leading Junior
Legal 500 2025 Leading Mediator
Legal 500 2025 Leading Set
Legal 500 2025 Included Clerk
Association of Personal Injury Lawyers
Chartered Institute of Arbitrators
Wellbeing at the Bar | Certificate of Recognition
Family Law Awards 2020 - Family Law Chambers of the Year
Civil Mediation Council
Family Law Bar Association
Professional Negligence Bar Association
Chancery Bar
Resolution first for family law