Sales And Leaseback Schemes A Cautionary Tale
If a deal looks too good to be true it probably is. This is the lesson learned by a group of householders in Hampshire and in the Newcastle area who signed up for a scheme whereby they sold their homes to an investment company which promised them an income and a life interest in their own home if in return they were to invest the sale proceeds with that company. Of course, the scheme only works on a rising market, especially when the investment company promptly mortgages the property to a lending institution and (in the case of the Hampshire scheme) fraudulently pretended to the lender that this was a normal domestic sale to one of the members of the company. When the instalments of mortgage went unpaid and possession proceedings followed, the lenders and the householders found out about each other for the first time. Since both are innocent victims of the scheme, who should lose out?
In the Hampshire cases we pleaded a series of defences, including fraud and overriding equitable interest but the cases were all stayed by consent whilst the High Court in Newcastle struggled with similar issues in the North East Property Buyers Litigation. There had been conflicting decisions of County Courts in similar situations, including Redstone Mortgages v Welch [2009] EGLR 71 which favoured the interest of the householders over the innocent mortgagees and Abbey National v Cann [1991] 1 AC 56 in which the interest of the mortgagees prevailed.
Now the Court of Appeal North East Property Buyers [2012] EWCA 17 has given us the definitive answer, in upholding the decision at first instance against the householders. The Court held that there was no moment in time between the leaseback contract and the mortgages in which an equitable interest could arise, and in any event the rights granted to the householders by the investment company were personal at best and could not over-ride the interests of the mortgagees. Moreover, the effect of s63 of the Law of Property Act 1925 was that occupiers could not rely on pre-completion equitable interests. Registration by the mortgagees completed the legal interest in their favour which prevailed over the householders. Prior to the registration of the transfer the grant of any lease took effect only in equity and did not fall within the Land Registration Act 2002 s.29.
As the Court said, the problems that had arisen for the householders could have been avoided if the contracts for sale had given details of the precise contractual arrangements that were to operate in relation to their occupation after completion. In the Hampshire cases, this did not happen due to the fraud of the investment company but it was always going to be difficult to visit this upon the mortgagees, who were innocent of any wrongdoing. It must have come as small comfort to the Hampshire householders that the businessmen behind the investment company in their cases received long sentences of imprisonment for fraud.
Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.














