The Credit Crunch A Dramatic Subsequent Event?
Any ancillary relief practitioners who have any clients left of any substantial wealth in this economic climate may have pondered the conundrum of what might happen if the recession causes a marked fall in the fortunes of one party to a compromise agreement. Would this be a Barder event? (Barder v Caluori [1988] AC 20 HL)
Guidance was given last month by the Court of Appeal decision of Myerson v Myerson [2009] EWCA Civ 282, in which the Appellant Husband appealed the order giving effect to the compromise agreement. Husband was a successful fund manager of a quoted company and its executive chairman. At the FDR the assets stood at £25.8million (substantially in shares of the company). It was agreed that Wife would receive £11million (43%) in instalments and Husband, £14.5million (57%). Wife would receive £9.5million in cash and the balance by transfer of a property. The first instalment of £7million was duly paid. At the date of compromise, the Husband's shares were valued at £2.99p each - worth £15million to the Husband. A year later the shares were only worth 27.5p each. The global financial crisis and thus the fall in his share values led the Husband to appeal; arguing the fall in value was a dramatic subsequent event rendering the order unfair and unworkable. Due to the drop, the assets now stood at £12.7million and if implemented as compromised meant the Husband would now receive 14% and the Wife, 86%.
The Court of Appeal rejected the appeal. The natural processes of price fluctuation were deemed not to be a Barder event. The Husband had agreed an asset division choosing his assets to be in his shares; his decision could in effect have led to an increase in values, that it did not did not constitute his right to re-open the bargain. Whilst we all know each case turns on its own facts this may be a salutary reminder to think creatively when drafting compromise agreements. If anyone has a similar case, one tip seems to emerge: Think of paying large lump sums by instalments, they are capable of variation via s31(2)(d), Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, and may be the only source of clawing something back by the Husband in the instant case!
Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.














