â??Unlock the equity in your propertyâ? scams Final word to the Supreme Court
Two years ago we published an article on this subject. Now the Supreme Court has given its definitive word on the law, in North East Property Buyers Litigation [2014] UKSC 52 (28th October 2014)
A group of householders in Hampshire and in the Newcastle area signed up for a scheme whereby they sold their homes to an investment company, which promised an income and a life interest in their own home in return for the investment of the sale proceeds with that company. Of course, the scheme only works on a rising market, especially when the investment company promptly mortgages the property to a lending institution and (in the case of the Hampshire scheme) fraudulently pretends to the lender that this was a normal domestic sale to one of the members of the company. When the instalments of mortgage go unpaid and possession proceedings follow, the lenders and the householders find out about each other for the first time. Since both are innocent victims of the scheme, who should lose out?
In the Hampshire cases we pleaded a series of defences, including fraud and overriding equitable interests but the cases were all stayed by consent whilst the High Court in Newcastle struggled with similar issues in the North East Property Buyers Litigation. There had been conflicting decisions of County Courts in similar situations, including Redstone Mortgages v Welch [2009] EGLR 71 which favoured the interest of the householders over the innocent mortgagees and Abbey National v Cann [1991] 1 AC 56 in which the interest of the mortgagees prevailed. All of the cases in Newcastle were lost at first instance and in the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court had to struggle with the same issues of fairness and the need for clarity in the law that everyone else did. Their Lordships agreed with the Court of Appeal that there was no moment in time between the leaseback contract and the execution of the mortgages in which an equitable interest could arise, and in any event the rights granted to the householders by the investment company were personal at best and could not override the interests of the mortgagees. Whilst on the face of it, the promises by the investment company to grant a continuing right of occupation bore the hallmarks of an equitable estoppel, the question was whether this could be an interest in land before the promisor became the legal owner. This in turn fed into the question of whether the completion could be divided from the grant of the mortgage, or whether there was one indivisible transaction.
Lords Collins and Sumption were clear in their conclusion that the completion and mortgage were an indivisible transaction, and Lady Hale and Lords Wilson and Reed thought that even if there were equitable rights in favour of the householder at the point of completion, the mortgage would still take priority over them. The argument that the combined effect of sections 29, 116 and 132 of the Land Registration Act 2002 was to create a proprietary interest in favour of the householder was rejected. Although the Court was unanimously in favour of the lenders however, there was a sharp division as to their reasoning. Lady Hale in particular disagreed with Lord Collins about the “indivisible transaction”. She pointed out that just as in Williams & Glyn’s Bank v Boland [1981] AC 487, the householder was in actual occupation at the time of the transaction(s) so why should there not be an overriding interest as was upheld in that case? Moreover, the lender is not a party to the sale transaction so why should the two transactions be considered as one? In the end, she managed to square this circle by concluding that a purchaser cannot create any proprietary interest in land before he actually completes on it, but she confessed to some “uneasiness” about that conclusion, with which I entirely agree. The argument we ran in the Hampshire cases was essentially to say that to look at the problem from the point of view of the lender was to put your eye to the wrong end of the telescope: the key question was to ask “how can a borrower create more of a right that he already has for himself?”
For policy reasons no doubt, their lordships disagreed. As Lord Collins said in the leading judgment, it would be impossible not to feel sympathy for the householders, many of whom had been victims of fraud by the investors and unscrupulous behaviour by solicitors. However the Court was also concerned that there are more than 23 million registered titles in England and Wales and the Land Registry may handle up to 75,000 house sales each month, most of which are financed by secured loans. The implications for the housing and lending market if the householders had succeeded could have been massively serious.
The problems that had arisen for the householders would of course have been avoided if the contracts for sale had given details of the precise contractual arrangements that were to operate in relation to their occupation after completion. In the Hampshire cases, this did not happen due to the fraud of the investment company but it was always going to be difficult to visit this upon the mortgagees, who were innocent of any wrongdoing.
The businessmen behind the investment company in the Hampshire cases received long sentences of imprisonment for fraud but the real mischief in these cases was the risky nature of sale and leaseback schemes. The Financial Services Authority recommended that this should become a Regulated Activity under Section 19 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, because the schemes were almost always unaffordable or unsuitable, and this has now been brought into effect, with the result that the sale and leaseback market is now almost non-existent. The problem for householders involved in these historic schemes remains.
Please note any article published on this website is not intended as legal advice and is to be considered to represent the opinions of the author at the time of publishing only. If you require legal advice, you are encouraged to contact a solicitor, complete the Direct Access Questionnaire or complete our ‘Contact Us’ form.














