Wider canvas cases â?? Non-accidental Injuries to Babies
Usually if you act for parents in a non-accidental injury fact find, you find yourself pinned against a wall with the weight of medical expert evidence pressing hard against you. But not always.
Published on BAILII today is the decision in Dorset Council v M (Failure to prove non-accidental injury) [2019] EWFC B63
See - http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWFC/OJ/2019/B63.html
In this case, I acted for the mother. The baby had skull fractures, and perfectly respectable experts concluded that the explanations given by the parents did not fit the injuries, and as such this was a case of non-accidental injury.
However, as experienced child law practitioners will know, whilst the experts advise, it is the court that decides and the judge has to look at ALL of the evidence using a “wide canvas”.
To cut a long story short, whilst on the one hand the experts said this was “non-accidental injury”, on the other hand the parents were compelling in their denial that anything bad had happened to the baby on their watch. As the trial judge said:
“The impression I have of these parents weighs heavily in my assessment. I am inclined to believe them.”
As such he found that the Local Authority had failed to discharge the burden of proof placed upon it, he found threshold was not crossed, and the baby returned home.
“Wider canvas” arguments don’t always work on behalf of parents in care proceedings (in fact they rarely do in my experience), but sometimes when that argument works, it REALLY works!
To instruct Anthony please contact our clerks on 023 8023 0338 or e-mail clerks@college-chambers.co.uk.














